Use AI to Amplify
Human Creativity.
Not Outsource It

Former Head of Community for Writers at OpenAI. Taught writing at Yale. Teaching people and companies how to use AI to support the creative process — not outsource it.

Jay Dixit speaking at Wharton
Jay Dixit speaking at Wharton about AI as a tool for creativity. (Hint: Don’t ask AI to be creative — ask it to help you be creative.)

Field Notes from a Creative Frontier

A Growing Community of Ethical AI Creators

When I was at OpenAI leading the writing community, my job was to seek out writers, educators, and students using AI thoughtfully and ethically in the creative process. What I found was a community of brilliant, curious people who see beyond the pro-AI / anti-AI hot-take binary.

These people hold human creativity sacred, yet they see AI’s potential. They know there are parts of the process we must preserve and defend. But they also understand that AI doesn’t have to replace human creativity — that used thoughtfully, it can be a powerful tool to help us fulfill our creative potential.

What started as a handful of early adopters has now become a movement. Writers and educators across the country are learning how to use AI as a tool to support their creative work — without ever compromising their authenticity or outsourcing their creativity.

Voices from the Community

Sarah Rose Siskind

Sarah Rose Siskind

Comedian and Comedy Writer

“What’s amazing to me is I do not have writer’s block anymore — like truly. I think writer’s block is the feeling of solipsism, and it is the feeling of being totally alone. And I don’t feel alone anymore because of this tool.”
Stew Fortier

Stew Fortier

Writer and Founder

“The instinct is to say, ‘Oh, this thing just writes for us.’ But I can also prompt it to ask me questions. It can get me thinking by pulling ideas and insights out of me. What if instead of you becoming a prompt engineer, you see what it can prompt out of you?”
Ken Liu

Ken Liu

Hugo Award Winner

“The amazing thing about a writers’ room is the way the intersubjectivity of working with other people multiplies your own creativity tenfold. Having the AI push you to be more original, push you to explain your idea... It allows you to get out of that ‘I’m locked in my head’ space.”
Subscribe to my Substack

Get weekly insights on how to use AI to amplify creativity — not replace it.

The Reframe

Don’t ask AI to be creative. Ask AI to help you be creative.

Most people fall into one of two camps:

❌ Anti-AI

Avoid AI entirely out of fear

❌ Pro-AI

Let AI do the writing

The divide reveals itself in how people talk about AI:

“I always know when my students are using AI.”

“It never gets my tone right.”

“It’s essentially just a plagiarism machine.”

These sentiments reveal a hidden assumption: that AI exists to do our work for us — that you either use it to generate writing or you don’t use it at all.

Socratic AI’s approach: Use AI to think better, not to think for you.

ChatGPT conversation showing Socratic AI approach

What I Believe

Three Paradoxes of Socratic AI

#1

Honor Human Creativity

THE PRINCIPLE

Human creativity is sacred. Writing, storytelling, and art are acts of creation, and we must never outsource them to AI.

THE PARADOX

AI doesn’t have to be a threat to creativity. Used thoughtfully, it can be a powerful tool to help us surface, develop, and express our own best ideas — without ever outsourcing the imagination, insight, and self-expression that make us human.

#2

Embrace the Struggle

THE PRINCIPLE

Creation is born of struggle. We must resist the urge to outsource the difficult parts to AI. Writing is hard — and that productive struggle is the whole point. The most powerful insights arise in those moments of discomfort and uncertainty when you’re staring down the blank page trying to figure out what comes next.

THE PARADOX

In those moments of doubt when you’re lost and stuck, AI can be a sounding board — a thinking partner to talk out your ideas, ask you clarifying questions, and help you find your way forward.

#3

Aim Higher

THE PRINCIPLE

The goal isn’t to work less — it’s to reach higher and achieve more. Work as hard as ever and, amplified by AI, produce more and better work.

THE PARADOX

Creative work demands focus. So do automate the grunt work. Let AI handle the formatting, the citations, the drudgery — so you can devote yourself to the acts of human imagination AI can’t replace.

These are not true paradoxes in the strict sense, since the statements don’t actually contradict each other. They’re maybe more like dialectics — matched truths, each in tension with its counterpart.

About Jay

Building a Movement of Ethical AI Creators

Meet Jay Dixit

Jay Dixit is a writer, Yale professor, and creator of the “Socratic AI” framework. He spent 10,000+ hours honing his craft as a writer — and when AI arrived, he knew immediately how to use it: not to generate writing, but to help him think and write better.

"AI is my writer's room."

Writer First, AI Advocate Second

Award-winning journalist for The New York Times, Rolling Stone, and Psychology Today. Conducted George Carlin’s final interview and won The Moth storytelling competition. When ChatGPT launched, Jay immediately saw its potential — not to generate writing, but to support the creative process.

Building the OpenAI Writing Community

As Head of Community for Writers at OpenAI, Jay sought out and connected with writers, educators, and creators exploring ethical ways to use AI. It was in conversations with this community that he first defined the “Socratic AI” approach.

The Movement Grows

What started as a small community has grown into a movement. Jay has shared the Socratic AI framework at Harvard, Wharton, Columbia, Yale, and through OpenAI’s flagship education resources — demonstrating that AI can amplify human creativity rather than replace it.

Today: Building the Movement

Through speaking, consulting, and the Socratic AI newsletter, Jay helps writers, educators, and institutions discover how to use AI thoughtfully — preserving what makes us human while harnessing technology’s potential.

Why It Matters

Refusing to engage with AI won’t make it go away. It just means we’re ceding the conversation to people who treat AI as a content factory.

If you hold creativity sacrosanct but want to explore AI’s possibilities... If you wince at AI slop but refuse to surrender the fight to growth hackers... If you believe AI should support human creativity, not replace it... then you’re in the right place.

The best way to defend human authenticity is for us to be the ones who shape how people use AI — and guide others toward using it in ways that honor human creativity.

Choose Your Path

Find Your Starting Point

Whether you're a knowledge worker, leading an academic institution, or building AI literacy in your organization, there's a path for you.

For Knowledge Workers

Use AI to surface your best ideas, break through blocks, and push your work further—without outsourcing your thinking.

  • Case studies from novelists, screenwriters & comedians
  • Reverse interviewing & brainstorming prompts
  • Access to the creator community
Start Here

For Organizations

Build AI literacy across your company. Empower teams to use AI thoughtfully and effectively while maintaining quality and authenticity.

  • Corporate training & workshops
  • AI adoption frameworks & best practices
  • Leadership keynotes & team enablement
Let's Talk

For Institutions

Transform how your university or school approaches AI in education. Turn AI from a cheating concern into a learning opportunity.

  • Faculty development & teaching strategies
  • AI-resilient curriculum & assessment design
  • Academic policy & implementation guidance
Let's Talk

Speaking

Signature Talks

Transformative sessions that help educators and institutions navigate the AI revolution with confidence and clarity.

Writing in the Age of AI

Keynote reframing AI as a thinking amplifier — perfect for faculty summits, ed-tech conferences, and leadership retreats. Attendees leave with 3 prompts they can use immediately.

How to Use ChatGPT Ethically & Effectively

Hands-on workshop covering prompting strategies, disclosure forms, and the Socratic AI framework for responsible AI use. Faculty walk away with 5 assignment templates.

Designing AI-Resilient Assignments

Turn memory checks into reasoning workouts and safeguard learning integrity with practical classroom strategies. Teachers know how to turn any essay prompt into a critical thinking challenge.

AI in Education: From Cheating to Curiosity

Real classroom strategies that turn AI into a springboard for critical thinking rather than a shortcut to answers.

Amplifying Creativity with AI

Stories of writers and artists using AI to push imagination while keeping the creative process fundamentally human.

Ethical AI for a Human-Centered Future

Practical frameworks for responsible AI use that aligns with transparency, fairness, and human values.

Using AI with Integrity

Custom strategies for organizations to harness AI thoughtfully — boosting productivity while fostering creativity.

Creative Brainstorming with AI

Techniques like reverse interviewing and analogy generation to spark fresh ideas and innovative solutions.

AI Literacy for Teams

Half-day introduction that demystifies AI and builds confident, skilled users across your organization.

Custom Talks

I also design custom sessions tailored to your institution's specific needs and challenges.

Core Philosophy

The Socratic AI Approach

A human-centered methodology that reframes AI as a collaborative thinking partner — one that helps you surface your best ideas, articulate your thoughts with greater clarity, and make connections you might not otherwise have reached.

Academic Excellence

Trusted by elite institutions worldwide

Harvard Wharton Columbia

Proven Impact

Measurable results that matter

10,000+
Students transformed

Ethical Leadership

Human-centered by design

  • Transparency first
  • No shortcuts
  • Human creativity

The Full Story

How My Socratic Questioning Approach Inspired ChatGPT’s New Study Mode

Spring 2024: Interviews with Writers and Educators

Inspired by my interviews with writing community members like Stew Fortier and Ken Liu, I begin exploring how to use AI to ask questions instead of just providing answers. The idea is simple: Flip the script and let AI ask the questions for a change.

Summer 2024: I Develop the Socratic Framework

I refine the “Socratic approach” through conversations with novelists, screenwriters, and writing professors. My radical idea: Rather than ban AI, we should teach students how to use AI to challenge and deepen their thinking.

Fall 2024: I Publish My Student Guide

I document my approach in the Student Writing Guide I publish on OpenAI.com in fall 2024, providing examples and strategies for educators and students.

AI Should Amplify Thinking, Not Replace It

My philosophy — that “productive struggle” is important to learning and that students should “use AI as a tool, not an answer machine” — becomes central to OpenAI’s education messaging.

August 2025: Inspiring a New Product

My Socratic approach leads to the development of a new product: ChatGPT Study Mode. Designed to foster deeper understanding, Study Mode asks Socratic-style questions and offers step-by-step guidance instead of quick answers. (Just to be clear: A “tutoring mode” — “Hey ChatGPT, teach me about ionic bonds” — was already in the works. The Socratic questioning was my contribution.)

Study Mode Launched

With the launch of Study Mode, “Socratic-style questions” become a core feature of ChatGPT — bringing my educational approach directly into the product that tens of millions of students now use every day.

Recognition

Media & Recognition

Featured in leading publications and trusted by elite institutions worldwide.

Featured In

The New York Times

Staff Writer

Psychology Today

Senior Editor

Rolling Stone

Contributor

Business Insider

Featured Expert

Speaking & Workshops

Harvard University

Harvard

Yale University

Yale

Columbia University

Columbia

Wharton School

Wharton

California State University

CSU

Join 2,000+ writers, educators, and knowledge workers. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Looking to implement this at your institution?

The newsletter is for individuals. For custom workshops, speaking, or consulting, let's talk.

Schedule a Consultation
-->

Ready to Transform Your 
Institution?

Let’s work together to harness AI’s potential — preserving what makes us human while amplifying our creative capacity. Whether through workshops, speaking engagements, or custom consulting — let’s build this future together.